Tuesday, July 5, 2011

Maimonides - Then and Now

In contemporary culture today, the name Maimonides stands for the mainstream Jewish Orthodoxy. Chabad (Lubavich Hasidic) sends in regular messages on line with special references to Maimonides’s books for daily study. A prominent Orthodox private school, called Maimonides, continues to have a great academic reputation in Boston, MA.

That was not always the case in the medieval period when the great philosopher lived, first in Cordoba, Spain and then in Fustat, Egypt. Moses Maimonides (1135-1204; called for short, Rambam) was deeply influenced by the teachings of Aristotle, and attempted to show that Judaism, too, with some restrictions, could be understood in light of Greek philosophy. Through his books, such as The Guide to the Perplexed, and the Commentary to the Mishnah, the rabbi-philosopher spoke of God as pure intellect, and insisted that God’s attributes were metaphors, which were understood and expressed only by our limited human minds.

Though Maimonides had many supporters, some of his contemporaries strongly disagreed with his rationalistic interpretation of Judaism. Soon, an anti-Maimonidean movement developed in southern France and Cataluña, which shook the foundations of the Jewish communities in the Mediterranean basin. Spearheaded by the Ravad of Posquieres (12th cent) and supported even by some of the great rabbinic luminaries, such as Solomon b. Abraham of Montpellier and Jonah b. Abraham of Girondi, the anti-Maimonidean movement declared the Rambam a heretic, and was instrumental in having his books publicly burned in Montpellier, southern France in 1233. As time went on, however, this negative attitude against Maimonides abated, and, in our time, few remember the fierce intellectual battles that medieval rabbis fought about this great Jewish-Spanish philosopher.

In our time, a new intellectual battle is raging between the Jewish rationalists and anti-rationalists -- each claiming that it best represents the Jewish tradition. Regrettably, the anti-rationalists appear to be denigrating the other possible approaches in Judaism. This would be a big mistake, because there is room within our tradition for both approaches, and no one should claim that it has the ultimate truth. As a rationalist myself, I would be very sad if this reality is ignored in the modern Jewish world.

Rifat Sonsino

This post originally appeared on Rabbi Sonsino's blog, “From Istanbul to Boston

1 comment:

  1. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nj9diMkY-4E

    In this video I'm sharing with you a bit of my long spiritual journey. It started from Eastern philosophy, meditation, yoga, Sai Baba, doing healing as Reiki, mystic therapy. Then I discovered that close to my roots there is much to find in Jewish Mysticism and I started to study the Kabbala.

    I started with Doctor Tali Loewenthal studying the Hasidic texts of the Tanya book. Then I had some classes with Rabbi Tatz. and my favourite teacher Jeremy Rosen who was the Rabbi of Yakar, as he combines Kabbala, philosophy and psychology in a very deep but also practical way. Then I studied two courses with the Kabbala Centre which is known to the world as a lot of celebrities like Madonna, Jerry Hall and many more have studied there.
    Then life took me to do a degree of BA in Jewish studies which I was exposed to the holiest texts in Kabbala like the book of creation and the Zohar but also study philosopher as Maimonides, Ramban, Spinoza Martin Buber. On the course I studied the history of Kabbala and the academic side of the way it all developed. All this mixture of knowledge brought me to a very balanced way of seeing life and please join in and watch my video.

    Everyone who enters gets a free download. To claim it go to http://www.tallykoren.com

    http://www.tallykoren.com / Facebook tallykoren / twitter @tallykoren / http://tallykoren.wordpress.com/

    ReplyDelete